- Have any questions?
- 480-631-7837
- support@in-goodhealth.com
Gluten and Dairy: The Hidden Thyroid Connection
April 28, 2026Gluten and Dairy: The Hidden Thyroid Connection
April 28, 2026
One of the most surprising things modern research has shown is this: a lot of people taking thyroid medication may never have needed it in the first place.
That is a big statement, and it needs to be handled carefully. This is not about telling everyone to throw out their pills. It is about recognizing that thyroid medication overprescription is real, and for many people, there may be a safe path to use less medication or even quit thyroid medication entirely.
The numbers are more encouraging than most people realize. About 80% of people in the relevant studies were able to reduce their dose, and roughly half of those were able to come off completely without adverse effects.
If you have ever wondered whether you actually still need levothyroxine or another thyroid prescription, there are a few key clues that can help predict your odds. There are also some very clear situations where trying to quit thyroid medication is not appropriate.
Recommended Product: The Deprescribing Bundle. If you and your doctor are considering a lower thyroid medication dose, your body still needs the right nutrients to function well during that process. The Deprescribing Bundle is designed to support thyroid hormone use and overall metabolic balance while medication needs are being reassessed.Click Here
Table of Contents
Who Should Not Try To Stop Thyroid Medication
I want to start with safety, because this absolutely is not for everyone.
You should not attempt to quit thyroid medication if any of the following apply:
- You do not have a thyroid gland. If it was surgically removed, your body cannot make enough thyroid hormone on its own.
- Your thyroid was destroyed by radioablation. Same issue. There is no meaningful thyroid function left to recover.
- Your thyroid is severely atrophied. If an ultrasound showed a thyroid volume below 5 cc, that is considered atrophic thyroiditis. Functionally, that is similar to not having a thyroid.
- You are pregnant or nursing. That is not the time to experiment with reducing medication.
- You do not have support from your prescribing doctor. This process should be supervised. You need a clinician who understands what is normal during a taper.
If you fall into one of those categories, trying to quit thyroid medication is not the right move right now.
The 3 Biggest Predictors Of Whether You Can Quit Thyroid Medication
Research points to three major factors that help predict whether someone can successfully reduce or stop treatment. These are not absolute rules, but they are useful signs.
1. How long you have been on treatment
In general, the shorter the time on thyroid medication, the better the odds. If you have been taking it for less than four or five years, that is a more favorable sign. Once someone has been on treatment longer than that, the odds of stopping do go down.
That said, “lower odds” does not mean “impossible.” People can still succeed after many years. In clinical experience, even someone on thyroid medication for decades can sometimes taper successfully. It just tends to require more care and patience.
2. Your current TSH while on medication
If your TSH on medication is below 1.8, that is another favorable sign. Why does that matter? Because it suggests your body may still be producing a meaningful amount of thyroid hormone on its own. In other words, the medication may not be doing all the work.
For someone thinking about whether they can quit thyroid medication, this can be an important clue that the thyroid still has reserve capacity.
3. Your current dose
The smaller your dose, the more likely it is that your body is already contributing. For T4-only medications such as levothyroxine or Synthroid, a lower dose generally means below 75 micrograms. For natural desiccated thyroid, a smaller dose is typically below 45 milligrams. If you are on one of these lower doses, your chances of being able to quit thyroid medication are better than someone who is taking a much larger amount.
These Factors Help, But They Do Not Decide Everything
This is where nuance matters.
The three factors above are positive predictors, but they are not hard barriers. Someone can still reduce levothyroxine or another thyroid prescription even if they have been on it a long time, have unstable levels, or are using a higher dose.
Why? Because many of the published studies looked at people who were simply told how to taper and sent on their way. They were not necessarily addressing nutrient deficiencies, iodine excess, iron status, or other thyroid-related issues that can affect outcomes.
That matters because thyroid medication overprescription is only part of the story. The other part is helping the body function as well as it can before trying to step down medication.
––Key takeaway: The three predictors are not hard barriers; success is still possible, especially by addressing nutrient deficiencies, iodine excess, and other thyroid-related issues before starting a taper.
Before You Taper: Prepare Your Thyroid
If you are considering whether to quit thyroid medication, one of the smartest things you can do is spend some time getting your body ready first.
Watch your iodine intake
This is a major point that gets missed all the time.
Thyroid medications contain iodine. If your total iodine intake from medication, diet, supplements, iodized salt, and even personal care products is too high, that can work against you.
A practical threshold mentioned here is around 200 micrograms per day. Above that, the body may become more resistant to thyroid hormones, and the thyroid may have a harder time recovering normal function.
So if your goal is to quit thyroid medication safely, getting a handle on iodine exposure matters.
Check key nutrient status
There are also several nutrient issues that can influence thyroid health and the tapering process.
Important ones include:
- Iron
- Selenium
- Zinc
- Vitamin D
- Magnesium
If these are low, addressing them can improve the odds of success. This does not guarantee that you can quit thyroid medication, but it can make the process smoother and more realistic.
How To Taper Thyroid Medication
There is not just one way to do this, but the standard process used in many studies is fairly straightforward.
A common taper is to reduce the dose by about 25% every two weeks. That creates a taper of roughly two months.
There are two basic ways to approach it:
- Use a full taper schedule upfront. You and your doctor create the plan, follow it, and recheck labs after the taper.
- Take one small step down, then reassess. You lower the dose modestly, wait a couple of months, recheck symptoms and labs, and then decide what comes next.
In practice, the slower and steadier method is often the better fit for most people. It makes the process less dramatic, gives the body time to respond, and allows for course correction if needed.
If someone is on a very tiny dose of levothyroxine and otherwise looks like an excellent candidate, a faster taper may be reasonable. But for many people, gradual reduction is simpler and less stressful.
What Lab Changes Are Normal During A Taper
This point is critical, because it is where many people get scared and many clinicians overreact.
When you reduce thyroid medication, it is normal for TSH to rise.
That rise does not automatically mean failure. In many cases, it is just the body signaling the thyroid gland to work harder again. That is exactly what you would expect during a successful transition.
The more important concern is what happens to free T4 and T3. If those levels simply shift or even move toward the lower end of normal, that may be acceptable. But if they flatline, that is a bad sign. It suggests the taper went too far or happened too quickly.
This is why trying to quit thyroid medication without a knowledgeable prescriber is a bad idea. You need someone who understands the difference between a normal temporary TSH rise and a true problem.
––Key takeaway: A rise in TSH during a taper is normal and signals the thyroid to work harder; however, flatlining free T4 and T3 is a bad sign, emphasizing the need for knowledgeable medical supervision.
Why This Conversation Matters
Many people were started on levothyroxine because they were “low optimal,” had borderline numbers, or had mild lab changes that did not necessarily justify lifelong treatment.
That is one reason thyroid medication overprescription has become such an important issue. Once medication begins, it often continues for years without anyone asking whether it is still needed.
And yet the data suggest that a meaningful percentage of people may be able to quit thyroid medication or at least use less of it. For those who were never clearly hypothyroid to begin with, the odds may be even better.
A Practical Way To Think About Your Chances
You may be a stronger candidate to quit thyroid medication if most of the following are true:
- You still have a functioning thyroid gland
- You are not pregnant or nursing
- Your doctor supports a supervised taper
- You have been on medication for less than 4 to 5 years
- Your TSH on medication is below 1.8
- Your dose is relatively low, such as a small amount of levothyroxine
- You have addressed excess iodine and nutrient deficiencies
The Bottom Line
If you have ever wondered whether you really need lifelong thyroid medication, it is a fair question.
For some people, the answer is yes. If you do not have a thyroid, if it has been destroyed, or if it is severely atrophied, replacement therapy is essential.
But for many others, especially in the setting of thyroid medication overprescription, there may be room to reassess. A lower dose of levothyroxine may be enough. In some cases, it may be possible to quit thyroid medication completely.
Thyroid medication can be life-changing when it is truly needed. But when it is not, people deserve to know that reassessment is possible. And in the right circumstances, learning how to quit thyroid medication may be one of the most important steps in getting back to a more natural baseline.
The key is to do it intelligently.
––Key takeaway: Know whether you are a reasonable candidate, prepare the body first, taper gradually, monitor labs with the right expectations and work with a doctor who understands the process.
P.S. Whenever you are ready, here is how I can help you now:
- Schedule a Thyroid Second Opinion with me, Dr. C, Click Here for Details
- Need help to choose supplements? Click ‘Help Me Decide Here'
- Get my top books Here
Dr. Alan Glen Christianson (Dr. C) is a Naturopathic Endocrinologist and the author of The NY Times bestselling Hormone Healing Cookbook, The Metabolism Reset Diet, and The Thyroid Reset Diet.
Dr. C’s gift for figuring out what works has helped hundreds of thousands reverse thyroid disease, heal their adrenals, and lose weight naturally. Learn more about the surprising story that started his quest.
